If you’re like most homeowners, your driveway doesn’t get much attention—until it starts looking like a patchy jigsaw puzzle. Maybe you’ve noticed cracks, potholes, or fading and now you’re asking, “Should I resurface or just rip the whole thing out and start fresh?” It’s a fair question—and one that can impact your budget and curb appeal for years to come.
A Few Cracks or Time to Start Over?
Resurfacing and replacing both fix worn driveways, but they’re not interchangeable. Resurfacing is like giving your driveway a new skin: a fresh asphalt layer goes over the existing surface to restore a smooth finish and extend its life. It’s faster and cheaper than a full replacement. But it only works when the foundation underneath is still in good shape.
On the flip side, a full replacement means tearing out the old asphalt and starting from the ground up. It’s more expensive, sure—but if the base layer is damaged or unstable, resurfacing is just putting lipstick on a pothole. Over time, those deeper issues will resurface—literally—and you’ll be right back at square one.
Signs It’s Time for More Than a Quick Fix
So how do you know which option makes sense? Start by taking a close look at the condition of your driveway. If it’s just a few surface cracks or slight fading, resurfacing might do the trick. But when the damage runs deeper, your best bet is to start over.
Here’s when it’s time to consider full replacement:
Deep, widespread cracks—especially those in a spiderweb or “alligator” pattern
Drainage problems like standing water or puddling
Potholes that keep reappearing even after patch jobs
Sinking or uneven surfaces from base failure
Multiple past overlays that make the surface too thick or unstable
According to the National Asphalt Pavement Association, a well-installed asphalt driveway lasts 20–25 years, but only with proper maintenance and repair timing. Waiting too long to address foundation problems can cost you more down the road—not to mention lower your home’s resale value or lead to safety hazards.
When in doubt, have a professional check the base layer. A solid foundation means you might be able to resurface and enjoy years of smooth driving. But if the underlying structure is shot, a full replacement is the smart long-term play.
Still unsure? RCM Paving can help with an honest assessment. Explore their Asphalt Driveways, Residential Asphalt Paving, Commercial Asphalt Services, or Contact RCM Paving to schedule a free, no-pressure consultation.